Tessa Wright, MJLST Staffer
The COVID-19 pandemic changed much about our daily lives, and nowhere have those changes been more visible than in the healthcare industry. During the pandemic, there were overflowing emergency rooms coupled with doctor shortages.[1] In-person medical appointments were canceled, and non-emergency patients had to wait months for appointments.[2] In response, the use of telehealth services began to increase rapidly.[3] In fact, one 2020 study found that telehealth visits accounted for less than 1% of health visits prior to the pandemic and increased to as much as 80% of visits when the pandemic was at its peak.[4] And, while the use of telehealth services has decreased slightly in recent years, it seems as though it is likely here to stay. Nowhere has the use of telehealth services been more prevalent than in mental health services.[5] Indeed, as of 2022, telehealth still represented over 36% of outpatient mental health visits.[6] Moreover, a recent study found that since 2020, over one in three mental health outpatient visits have been delivered by telehealth.[7] And while this increased use in telehealth services has helped make mental health services more affordable and accessible to many Americans, this shift in the way healthcare is provided also comes with new legal concerns that have yet to be fully addressed.
Privacy Concerns for Healthcare Providers
One of the largest concerns surrounding the increased use of telehealth in mental health services is privacy. There are several reasons for this. The primary concern has been due to the fact that telehealth takes place over the phone or via personal computers. When using personal devices, it is nearly impossible to ensure HIPAA compliance. However, the majority of healthcare providers now offer telehealth options that connect directly to their private healthcare systems, which allows for more secure data transmission.[8] While there are still concerns surrounding this issue, these secure servers have helped mitigate much of the concern.[9]
Privacy Concerns with Mental Health Apps
The other privacy concern surrounding the use of telehealth services for mental health is a little more difficult to address. This concern comes from the increased use of mental health apps. Mental health apps are mobile apps that allow users to access online talk therapy and psychiatric care.[10] With the increased use of telehealth for mental health services, there has also been an increase in the use of these mental health apps. Americans are used to their private medical information being protected by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA).[11] HIPAA is a federal law that creates privacy rules for our medical records and other individually identifiable health information during the flow of certain health care transactions.[12] But HIPAA wasn’t designed to handle modern technology.[13] The majority of mental health apps are not covered by HIPAA rules, meaning that these tech companies can sell the private health data from their apps to third parties, with or without consent.[14] In fact, a recent study that analyzed 578 mental health-related apps found that nearly half (44%) of the apps shared users’ personal health information with third parties.[15] This personal health information can include psychiatric diagnoses and medication prescriptions, as well as other identifiers including age, gender, ethnicity, religion, credit score, etc.[16]
In fact, according to a 2022 study, a popular therapy app, BetterHelp, was among the worst offenders in terms of privacy.[17] “BetterHelp has been caught in various controversies, including a ‘bait and switch’ scam where it advertised therapists that weren’t actually on its service, poor quality of care (including trying to provide gay clients with conversion therapy), and paying YouTube influencers if their fans sign up for therapy through the app.”[18]
An example of information that does get shared is the intake questionnaire.[19] An intake questionnaire needs to be filled out on BetterHelp, or other therapy apps, in order for the customer to be matched with a provider.[20] The answers to these intake questionnaires were specifically found to have been shared by BetterHelp with an analytics company, along with the approximate location and device of the user.[21]
Another example of the type of data that is shared is metadata.[22] BetterHelp can share information about how long someone uses the app, how long the therapy sessions are, how long someone spends sending messages on the app, what times someone logs into the app, what times someone sends a message or speaks to their therapists, the approximate location of the user, how often someone opens the app, and so on.[23] According to the ACLU, data brokers, Facebook, and Google were found to be among the recipients of other information shared from BetterHelp.[24]
It is also important to note that deleting an account may not remove all of your personal information, and there is no way of knowing what data will remain.[25] It remains unclear how long sensitive information that has been collected and retained could be available for use by the app.
What Solutions Are There?
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services recently released updated guidance on HIPAA, confirming that the HIPAA Privacy Rule does not apply to most health apps because they are not “covered entities” under the law.[26] Additionally, the FDA put out guidance saying that it is going to use its enforcement discretion when dealing with mental health apps.[27] This means that if the privacy risk seems to be low, the FDA is not going to enforce or chase these companies.[28]
Ultimately, if mental telehealth services are here to stay, HIPAA will need to be expanded to cover the currently unregulated field of mental health apps. HIPAA and state laws would need to be specifically amended to include digital app-based platforms as covered entities.[29] These mental health apps are offering telehealth services, similar to any healthcare provider that is covered by HIPAA. Knowledge that personal data is being shared so freely by mental health apps often leads to distrust, and due to those privacy concerns, many users have lost confidence in them. In the long run, regulatory oversight would increase the pressure on these companies to show that their service can be trusted, potentially increasing their success by growing their trust with the public as well.
Notes
[1] Gary Drenik, The Future of Telehealth in a Post-Pandemic World, Forbes, (Jun. 2, 2022), https://www.forbes.com/sites/garydrenik/2022/06/02/the-future-of-telehealth-in-a-post-pandemic-world/?sh=2ce7200526e1.
[2] Id.
[3] Id.
[4] Madjid Karimi, et. al., National Survey Trends in Telehealth Use in 2021: Disparities in Utilization and Audio vs. Video Services, Office of Health Policy (Feb. 1, 2022).
[5] Shreya Tewari, How to Navigate Mental Health Apps that May Share Your Data, ACLU (Sep. 28, 2022).
[6] Justin Lo, et. al., Telehealth has Played an Outsized Role Meeting Mental Health Needs During the Covid-19 Pandemic, Kaiser Family Foundation, (Mar. 15, 2022), https://www.kff.org/coronavirus-covid-19/issue-brief/telehealth-has-played-an-outsized-role-meeting-mental-health-needs-during-the-covid-19-pandemic/.
[7] Id.
[8] Supra note 1.
[9] Id.
[10] Heather Landi, With Consumers’ Health and Privacy on the Line, do Mental Wellness Apps Need More Oversight?, Fierce Healthcare, (Apr. 21, 2021), https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/tech/consumers-health-and-privacy-line-does-digital-mental-health-market-need-more-oversight.
[11] Peter Simons, Your Mental Health Information is for Sale, Mad in America, (Feb. 20, 2023), https://www.madinamerica.com/2023/02/mental-health-information-for-sale/.
[12] Supra note 5.
[13] Supra note 11.
[14] Id.
[15] Deb Gordon, Using a Mental Health App? New Study Says Your Data May Be Shared, Forbes, (Dec. 29, 2022), https://www.forbes.com/sites/debgordon/2022/12/29/using-a-mental-health-app-new-study-says-your-data-may-be-shared/?sh=fe47a5fcad2b.
[16] Id.
[17] Supra note 11.
[18] Id.
[19] Supra note 5.
[20] Id.
[21] Id.
[22] Id.
[23] Id.
[24] Id.
[25] Supra note 5.
[26] Id.
[27] Supra note 10.
[28] Id.
[29] Supra note 11.
